---
title: "VPN: ranked reviews and comparisons"
description: "VPN providers compared on the price you actually pay (the renewal, not the two-year promo), plus who owns them, where they answer to, whether the no-logs claim was audited, and the features a small team needs: fixed IP, device-to-device networking, SSO."
canonical: "https://saaskly.com/category/vpn"
last-updated: "2026-09-07"
---

# VPN: ranked reviews and comparisons

> VPN providers compared on the price you actually pay (the renewal, not the two-year promo), plus who owns them, where they answer to, whether the no-logs claim was audited, and the features a small team needs: fixed IP, device-to-device networking, SSO.

- Last updated: 2026-09-07

## Ranking

Ranked by Saaskly's editorial score (0–5). Ties share a rank. Method: https://saaskly.com/editorial-policy.md

1. **1. [Proton VPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/proton-vpn.md)**: 4.5/5. The VPN we run our own business on: Swiss jurisdiction, a non-profit foundation as the largest shareholder, five consecutive public no-logs audits, open-source apps, Secure Core, Stealth and port forwarding on every paid plan (from £2.79 a month on the two-year deal, £5.59 to renew), with a usable free tier and a business tier that adds fixed IPs and SSO.
2. **2. [NordVPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/nordvpn.md)**: 4.3/5. The biggest consumer VPN and the most complete on the "businessey" features a small team asks for: Meshnet device-to-device networking (kept, after a 2025 reprieve), dedicated UK IPs as an add-on, post-quantum NordLynx and six annual Deloitte audits. It is undercut by the steepest renewal cliff in the field: £2.59 a month on the two-year deal, renewing at £104.28 a year.
3. **3. [Mullvad](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/mullvad.md)**: 4.1/5. The honesty benchmark: €5 a month since 2009, no discounts, no renewal games, no email address needed, cash accepted, RAM-only servers, a police raid that found nothing, and public audits every year, but five devices, no fixed IP, no team plan, email-only support and WireGuard only.
4. **4. [Tailscale](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/tailscale.md)**: 4.0/5. The device-to-device network done properly: a WireGuard mesh between your own machines with SSO, SCIM, access policies and an API on flat per-user pricing, free for up to six users. It is not a privacy VPN unless you add a Mullvad exit node for $5 a month per five devices, and there is no fixed IP.
5. **5. [Windscribe](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/windscribe.md)**: 3.8/5. The independent's VPN: founder-owned, no two-year plan on principle, $69 a year that renews at $69, unlimited devices, a $2-a-month London static IP, a $5-a-seat team plan and a 10 GB free tier, with open-source apps, a founder acquitted in a Greek court for having no logs, and one honestly disclosed 2021 server-seizure lapse.
6. **6. [Private Internet Access](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/private-internet-access.md)**: 3.5/5. The cheapest full-featured VPN here (£1.67 a month over 39 months, renewing at the same £65), with unlimited devices, open-source apps, port forwarding, a UK dedicated IP at £2.25 a month and three Deloitte no-logs audits; but a US company owned by Kape, no team features, and Trustpilot renewal complaints that do not match the pricing page.
7. **7. [Surfshark](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/surfshark.md)**: 3.3/5. NordVPN's cheaper sister: unlimited devices, RAM-only servers, four UK cities, Deloitte-audited, a London dedicated IP add-on, all sold on a £2.19-a-month headline that is ex VAT, A/B-tested, and renews at £6.10, a 179% step; no device-to-device network, a USD-only team plan with no fixed IP, and a US auto-renewal class action on the record.
8. **8. [NordLayer](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/nordlayer.md)**: 3.2/5. Nord Security's business network: per-user pricing from $8 with a five-seat floor, SSO on every plan, UK dedicated servers in London and Manchester, but every feature a small business actually wants (fixed IP, site-to-site, device-to-device "Cloud LAN", cloud firewall) sits on top of a $40-a-month server and mostly the $14 Premium tier, it logs by design, and it has no Trustpilot profile and no API.
9. **9. [Cloudflare WARP / Zero Trust](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/cloudflare-warp.md)**: 3.0/5. Free for a team of up to 50, $7 a user after that, with SSO, SCIM, device posture, a Linux client and, since April 2026, Cloudflare Mesh for device-to-device traffic; but it is not a privacy VPN: you cannot choose an exit country, Cloudflare keeps source and destination IPs for up to two years, no audit has ever covered WARP, the client is closed source, and a fixed IP is Enterprise-only.
10. **10. [ExpressVPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/expressvpn.md)**: 2.7/5. The most heavily advertised VPN, technically excellent (KPMG-audited no-logs, RAM-only TrustedServer, the open-source Lightway protocol, seven UK locations, UK dedicated IPs from £2.99), and last in this comparison for what sits around it: an owner with an adware past that also owns the "review" sites that recommend it, a 2021 hacking-for-hire case involving its CIO, two Windows leaks in two years, and a £2.19 headline that renews at £5.83.

## Comparison table

| Provider | Rating | Month-to-month | Longest plan, per month | Renewal, per month | Renewal premium* | Pricing pattern | Type | Jurisdiction | Owner | No-logs audit | Devices | Fixed IP | Device-to-device network | WireGuard | Port forwarding | UK servers | Business plan | SSO | Linux client | Open-source apps | API | MCP server | Trustpilot (reviews)† |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Proton VPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/proton-vpn.md) | 4.5/5 | £7.99/mo | £2.79/mo (24-month term) | £5.59/mo | 100% | Intro discount | Privacy VPN | Switzerland | Proton AG (Proton Foundation largest shareholder) | Securitum, 2026 | 10 | Business plans only, UK available | Not offered | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.2 (983) |
| [NordVPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/nordvpn.md) | 4.3/5 | £11.09/mo | £2.59/mo (27-month term) | £8.69/mo | 236% | Intro discount | Privacy VPN | Panama | Nord Security | Deloitte, 2025 (summary only) | 10 | Paid add-on: £5.09/mo, UK available | Included | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | Yes | No | No | No | 4.2 (50,209) |
| [Mullvad](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/mullvad.md) | 4.1/5 | €5/mo | €5.00/mo | €5.00/mo | 0% | Flat | Privacy VPN | Sweden | Independent | Cure53 / X41 / Assured, 2025 | 5 | Not offered | Not offered | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | 3.4 (186) |
| [Tailscale](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/tailscale.md) | 4.0/5 | $8/mo | $8.00/mo | $8.00/mo | 0% | Per user | Mesh overlay | United States (contracts); Canada (HQ) | Independent | n/a (no exit servers) | Unlimited | Not offered | Core feature | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 3.7 (23) |
| [Windscribe](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/windscribe.md) | 3.8/5 | $9/mo | $5.75/mo | $5.75/mo | 0% | Flat | Privacy VPN | Canada | Independent | Packetlabs, 2024 | Unlimited | Paid add-on: $2.00/mo, UK available | Not offered | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | 4.7 (13,286) |
| [Private Internet Access](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/private-internet-access.md) | 3.5/5 | £9.99/mo | £1.67/mo (39-month term) | £1.81/mo | 8% | Intro discount | Privacy VPN | United States (Colorado) | Kape Technologies | Deloitte, 2025 | Unlimited | Paid add-on: £2.25/mo, UK available | Not offered | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | 4.3 (10,994) |
| [Surfshark](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/surfshark.md) | 3.3/5 | £13.79/mo | £2.19/mo (27-month term) | £6.10/mo | 179% | Intro discount | Privacy VPN | Netherlands (entity); British Virgin Islands (governing law) | Nord Security | Deloitte, 2025 (summary only) | Unlimited | Paid add-on: £2.77/mo, UK available | Not offered | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No | 4.3 (31,182) |
| [NordLayer](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/nordlayer.md) | 3.2/5 | $8/mo | $6.40/mo | $6.40/mo | 0% | Per user | Zero-trust access | United States (entity); England and Wales (governing law) | Nord Security | Not audited | 6 | Business plans only: $40.00/mo, UK available | Business plans only | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | No | — |
| [Cloudflare WARP / Zero Trust](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/cloudflare-warp.md) | 3.0/5 | Free ($7/mo paid tier) | Free | Free | — | Per user | Zero-trust access | United States | Cloudflare, Inc. | Not audited | Unlimited | Business plans only, no UK IP | Included | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | 1.4 (1,309) |
| [ExpressVPN](https://saaskly.com/category/vpn/expressvpn.md) | 2.7/5 | £10.99/mo | £2.19/mo (28-month term) | £5.83/mo | 166% | Intro discount | Privacy VPN | British Virgin Islands | Kape Technologies (Unikmind / Teddy Sagi) | KPMG, 2025 | 10 | Paid add-on: £2.99/mo, UK available | Not offered | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No | 4.4 (28,883) |

*Renewal premium: how much more the longest plan costs per month after its introductory term than during it, as a percentage of the intro rate. VPNs advertise the intro rate; you pay the renewal every term after. 0% means the advertised price is the real price. Prices are per month, effective (plan total ÷ months), as shown to a UK visitor on the research date, in the currency the vendor bills UK customers in; see each profile for the VAT basis.

†Trustpilot: uk.trustpilot.com TrustScore and review count on the research date. Three cells are weak signals and are shown for completeness: Cloudflare (1.4) is mostly non-customers blocked by CAPTCHAs on other companies' websites and no review mentions WARP; Tailscale (23 reviews) and Mullvad (186) are tiny unprompted samples. NordLayer has no Trustpilot profile, so its cell is blank.

## Articles

- [Best VPN Providers for UK Business in 2026: Proton Wins, NordVPN Runs It Close, Mullvad Sets the Honesty Benchmark, and the £2 Deals That Cost £6 a Month](https://saaskly.com/comparisons/best-vpn-providers-2026.md): Comparison. We compared ten VPN providers on the price you actually pay after the two-year promo ends, on who owns them and where they answer to, on whether the no-logs claim was independently audited, and on the features a small team needs: fixed IP, device-to-device networking, SSO. Proton VPN wins; NordVPN is the runner-up on capability. We explain why Mullvad and Tailscale rank above the big brands, why Cloudflare's free tier is marked down, and why ExpressVPN is last.

---

Researched and drafted with AI assistance; reviewed and approved by Tim Meredith. See https://saaskly.com/ai-transparency.md and https://saaskly.com/editorial-policy.md.

Canonical HTML: https://saaskly.com/category/vpn · Markdown index: https://saaskly.com/llms.txt